photo by Chris Otsen
THE CREAMERY
The Creamery at Winter Hill Farm has grown and evolved, from small farmstead dairy to a collaborative local creamery. Jim Stampone and Kate Leyroyer started the creamery in 2006 with a small herd a Randall Lineback cattle. Their goal was to preserve the rare-breed tri-purpose cattle, and they supported that effort by selling raw milk, developing the whole-milk cream-top yogurt recipe that we still use today, and making aged cheddar cheese.
When Steve and Sarah transitioned onto the farm in 2011, Steve grew the dairy herd by adding Jerseys to milk alongside the Randalls, and Sarah grew the creamery business by focusing on developing new cheeses, including Tideline, Frost Gully and Bradbury Mountain Blue. In 2014 they undertook the first major creamery expansion, adding new cheese drying, aging, and packing space. Cheese production grew, and in 2018, Winter Hill Farm began sourcing additional bulk milk for cheese production from Maine Milkhouse Farm in South Monmouth, Maine.
In 2025, with a growing demand for Cheese and milk production limited by land base constraints, the farm decided to focus solely on cheese and yogurt production, and transitioned to purchasing 100% of it’s milk directly from high-quality organic dairy herds in the area. This new collaboration has allowed Winter Hill to focus on the creamery while providing a steady, direct market for small organic farms making cheese-quality milk.
When the dairy cows left in 2025, work began on the second major creamery expansion. The old tie-stall milking barn and milk room, which were adjacent to the existing creamery, underwent a radical transformation. The milking barn was renovated to provide additional floor space for cheese drying, packing, refrigeration and warehousing, more than doubling the production space. The first batches of cheese made with 100% organic milk from Milkhouse Farm were made in April 2026.